How Can You Avoid Getting a Fake Montecristo Cigar? https://www.zupyak.com/p/30918....07/t/how-can-you-avo cigars have a relatively thin yet distinct band that can help you determine if it's real. The bands have a reddish-brown color that resembles the color of a bean. It is glossy, so it's quite shiny when you hold it under the light.